Why Soup Feels So Good When You’re Sick

When you’re sick, someone almost always offers you soup. In South Korea, one healing soup contains a whole chicken stuffed with rice and ginseng. In China, an herbal broth simmered for hours is offered. In a Jewish kitchen, chicken in a pot with noodles is a culinary remedy. While recipes differ, the instinct behind them is the same: Something about soup has to do with what happens in the pot.

As a nutritionist and naturopath, I see soup as everyday self-care, not just something for sick days. Learning what happens in the pot can help you make nourishing soups with your favorite ingredients. The clinical evidence for soup as a remedy is limited, but simmering has real advantages. Soup is also one of the easiest meals to make when you’re tired.

What Simmering Does to Food

Cooking does more than soften food. Heat frees up nutrients and can break down the tough cell walls of plants, making some nutrients more accessible during digestion.

A 2010 laboratory study found that stir-frying vegetables, including pumpkin, with a small amount of oil increased the amount of beta-carotene released during simulated digestion. The study did not test soup or measure absorption in people, but it illustrated how cooking and fat can work together. A drizzle of oil in a squash soup is a simple way to put this into practice.

Soup has another advantage: you drink what the vegetables leave behind. Because you don’t discard the cooking liquid, you retain nutrients that migrate into the water. Longer simmering is not automatically better, though, because heat can break down nutrients such as vitamin C. Nor does a soft texture guarantee easy digestion: Beans or onions may still cause discomfort for someone who is sensitive to them.

Bones give broth its body. Simmering bones and connective tissue turns some collagen into gelatin, which gives cooled broth its jellylike texture. Your body breaks the protein into smaller building blocks during digestion. The amount varies, so homemade broth is not equivalent to a measured collagen supplement.

Minerals in broths are present, but in modest amounts. Some minerals move from bones into the cooking liquid, but bone broth’s reputation overstates it. A 2017 study found that the commercial broths tested supplied, on average, less than 5 percent of daily calcium and magnesium requirements per serving. Think of broth as a foundation, with vegetables, legumes, and other substantial ingredients adding nourishment to the bowl.

What Warmth, Hydration, and Comfort Add

Part of soup’s appeal comes from the warmth and comfort it provides. Some of those effects have been studied.

In a study of 15 healthy adults, sipping hot chicken soup or hot water helped nasal mucus move more quickly. Researchers suggested that inhaling warm water vapor helped explain the effect. Although the effect was temporary, a warm bowl of soup may help keep mucus moving.

Warmth also brings aroma to the foreground. Heating generally helps volatile compounds escape from food, making the scent of ginger, herbs, or simmered vegetables more noticeable. Those aromas contribute to the flavor we experience as we eat. Smell may also influence when we feel full. Aroma may contribute to the sensory signals that help us decide when we have had enough to eat.

In a controlled study using tomato soup, participants ate 9 percent less when exposed to a stronger aroma for longer. The experiment delivered aromas through a nasal tube, suggesting that smell can influence how much we eat, although it doesn’t prove that a more fragrant soup will make you feel full for longer.

Then there is the comfort of familiarity. In a 2011 study, eating chicken soup prompted thoughts about relationships among people who considered it a comfort food. This suggests that some of soup’s comfort comes from its associations with people and care, which may help explain why a familiar bowl of soup feels reassuring when we are unwell.

A Shared Language of Care

Across cultures and centuries, soup has been the food of care. The 12th-century Jewish physician Maimonides recommended chicken broth for the weak and sick. Chicken noodle soup was popular in China during the Song dynasty, from 960 to 1279. In Korea, samgyetang combines chicken, rice, ginseng, and other ingredients in a restorative meal eaten in summer.

Chinese food therapy, which uses food to support health, treats soups as both nourishment and personalized care. In traditional Chinese medicine (TCM), soup ingredients are chosen with both the person and the season in mind.

“There are soups for everyday use that the whole family can share, and another type based on a person’s health condition,” Serene Feng, an acupuncturist, Epoch Times contributor, and Chinese herbalist, told The Epoch Times.

For Feng, choosing the right soup starts with knowing who will be eating it.

“A good restaurant may offer good food, but it still may not make the soup that’s right for your family,” she said. “TCM offers more customized soups to have at home.”

In practice, this means choosing ingredients to suit a person’s symptoms, usual tendencies, and the season. Within this traditional framework, someone who often feels cold might be given warming ingredients, such as ginger, while someone experiencing dryness might receive foods considered moistening, such as pears.

Make the Soup Work for You

When you are tired or under the weather, convenience matters. Leftover chicken, frozen vegetables, and ready-made broth can become soup without an elaborate shopping list. The aim is nourishment without turning cooking into a chore.

Start with ingredients you enjoy, then consider what each brings to the pot: the base is broth or stock; the substance comes from chicken, tofu, beans, or lentils; add vegetables for variety and fiber, plus ginger, herbs, and spices for flavor.

Scraps can get a second life here. Vegetable trimmings, such as skins and fibrous zests or leaves, add extra flavor before you strain them out, and keeping suitable scraps in a freezer container gives your next soup a head start. Onion skins are a good example: their papery outer layers contain quercetin, a plant compound with antioxidant properties that researchers have extracted using water heated under pressure.

TCM suggests matching ingredients to the season. In Chinese food therapy, pears are traditionally considered moistening for the lungs, countering the dryness associated with autumn and the colder months. Asian varieties, including Chinese snow pears, are common choices for traditional pear soups. They have a mild sweetness and stay crisp and juicy when ripe, unlike European varieties such as Bartlett, which soften as they ripen.

“The good thing about pear soup is that it can be made by itself, without putting in any other ingredients,” Feng said.

Pears also add fiber to soups, supporting bowel regularity. To keep the fiber, leave the softened fruit in the soup, whether in pieces or blended instead of straining it out.

Chinese yam is another ingredient Feng turns to regularly, with a long history of use in Chinese food therapy.

“Chinese yam is one we put in almost all the soups,” she said. “If it’s for the family, for general health, we use fresh Chinese yam.” It’s a long tuber with pale brown skin and white flesh, sold at Asian grocery stores as shan yao or nagaimo, and it supplies starchy carbohydrates for energy along with some fiber. Sweet potato is a practical substitute in soup, though its texture and nutrients differ.

2 Seasonal Soups

These two seasonal soups warm the body through the autumn and winter months.

Ginger, Squash, and Pear Soup

This soup is an adaptation of one by Dr. Serene Lee, based on Chinese food therapy using ingredients found in local U.S. markets.

Servings: 3 to 4

Ingredients

• 1 tablespoon extra-virgin olive oil

• 1 small onion, chopped

• 1 leek, white and light-green parts, washed and chopped

• 2 celery stalks, chopped

• 1 tablespoon grated fresh ginger

• 4 cups peeled, cubed butternut squash

• 1 ripe pear, cored and chopped

• 4 cups low-sodium vegetable broth

• Lemon juice, salt, and pepper, to taste

Method

1. Heat the oil in a large pot over medium heat. Add the onion, leek, and celery. Cook, stirring, until softened, about 6 to 8 minutes.

2. Add the ginger and cook for another minute.

3. Add the squash, pear, and broth. Bring to a boil, then reduce to a gentle simmer.

4. Partially cover and cook until the squash is tender, approximately 20 to 25 minutes.

5. Blend with an immersion blender until smooth, or leave some pieces for texture. Add water or broth to thin if needed.

6. Finish with lemon juice, salt, and pepper.

Western-Style Coconut Chicken and Broccoli Soup

My version of an American classic—broccoli and cheese soup—that’s extra nourishing with added protein.

Servings: 3 to 4

Ingredients

• 1 tablespoon extra-virgin olive oil

• 1 leek, white and light-green parts, washed and chopped

• 4 cups low-sodium chicken or vegetable broth

• 3 cups cooked, shredded chicken

• 4 cups small broccoli florets

• 3/4 cup unsweetened canned coconut milk

• Lemon juice, salt, and pepper, to taste

Method:

1. Heat the oil in a large pot over medium heat. Add the leek and cook until softened, about 5 to 6 minutes.

2. Add the broth and bring to a gentle simmer.

3. Stir in the chicken and broccoli. Simmer until the chicken is hot throughout and the broccoli is tender, approximately 5 to 7 minutes.

4. Lower the heat, stir in the coconut milk, and warm gently.

5. Finish with lemon juice, salt, and pepper.

There’s a magic ingredient in every good soup. “When making soup for your family, you need to put your love into it,” Feng said.

That care need not involve rare ingredients or hours at the stove. It can be a familiar flavor, a texture someone finds comforting, or extra portions saved in the fridge or freezer for tomorrow. You do not have to wait for illness to remember the warmth and goodness soup can bring.

Sheridan Genrich, BHSc., is a registered clinical nutritionist and naturopath whose consulting practice since 2009 has specialized in helping people who struggle with digestive discomfort, addictions, sleep, and mood disturbances. She is also the author of the self help book, "DNA Powered Health; Unlock Your Potential to Live with Energy and Ease."
You May Also Like