Commentary
Part I can be read here.
Depending on the province, between 20 percent and 56 percent of Canadian students cannot read proficiently by Grade 4. Children who have not learned to read by the end of Grade 3 rarely catch up. And the most recent Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA) scores show today’s Grade 10 students are two to three years behind their peers of 25 years ago—again, depending on the province.
Such gaps are not inevitable. They reflect choices about how reading is taught, as a new study by the Aristotle Foundation for Public Policy finds .
The Canadian education system tends to favour “balanced literacy.” This approach often relies on cueing strategies. Children are encouraged to guess unfamiliar words from pictures, context, or the first letter, rather than to decode them. But cognitive science does not support approaches relying on cueing and discovery.
The result is that too few children are learning how to read.
The solution is not a mystery. The Ontario Human Rights Commission’s 2022 Right to Read report states, “Decades of multidisciplinary research has shown that the best way to teach all students to read words is through direct, explicit, systematic instruction in foundational word-reading skills.”
Let’s unpack the research in plain English.
Reading depends on more than the ability to sound out words. Students need vocabulary and background knowledge to understand what they read. As educator E.D. Hirsch has argued, readers draw on shared cultural and subject knowledge to grasp a text’s meaning, including what is implied rather than stated. Research has shown that a student with limited reading ability but substantial knowledge of a subject can understand a text better than a stronger reader who knows little about it.
Bottom line: A knowledge-rich curriculum supports literacy.
Students also need to be taught phonological awareness—the ability to recognize and manipulate speech sounds—as well as morphological awareness. The latter is about understanding the parts of a word—such as roots, prefixes and suffixes, and syntactic awareness—and how grammatical structures shape meaning.
Combined with phonics, this is what is known as “structured literacy.”
The evidence favours a structured literacy approach to teaching. In summary, this requires systematic and explicit teaching of decoding, phonological and morphological awareness, knowledge-rich curriculum, and both writing and oral language. It also requires regular assessment so teachers can identify students having difficulties and provide additional help. Early intervention is essential.
Taken together, this approach benefits all students and is particularly important for those with dyslexia or other reading challenges.
Why, then, has reform been so slow?
The Right to Read inquiry identified deeply rooted resistance within the education establishment. In Ontario, teachers’ unions challenged mandatory early-reading screening on the grounds that it interfered with professional judgment. In British Columbia, the teachers’ federation has argued that teachers should determine how literacy is taught in their classrooms. Yet the Right to Read inquiry found that many Ontario teachers had not been taught evidence-based reading methods because faculties of education had failed to provide that training.
In 2024, Dyslexia Canada executive director Alicia Smith told The Tyee, “The roadblock is within your universities and, to a certain extent, bureaucrats within your Ministry of Education.” We agree.
The problem persists nationally. Dyslexia Canada’s provincial assessment reports that only four provinces—Alberta, New Brunswick, Nova Scotia, and Ontario—had removed balanced literacy cueing strategies from curriculum and instructional guidance. Even those provinces had not updated teacher-licensing requirements to ensure new teachers were proficient in structured literacy. No province had made evidence-based reading interventions mandatory.
The question is no longer whether we know how to teach children to read.
Canada does not lack research, recommendations, or examples of successful practice. What it lacks is the institutional resolve to act. Provinces must require evidence-based reading instruction, ensure teacher-education programs teach the science of reading, build knowledge-rich curricula, and introduce universal screening and effective early intervention.
Canadian children cannot afford another generation of educational inaction.
David W. Livingstone, Ph.D., is a senior fellow with the Aristotle Foundation for Public Policy, a retired professor of Liberal Studies and Political Studies, and an honorary research associate at Vancouver Island University.
Views expressed in this article are the opinions of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of The Epoch Times.

