Too Many Canadian Children Are Falling Behind in Reading. Why Aren’t We Fixing It?

By David Livingstone
David Livingstone
David Livingstone
David W. Livingstone, Ph.D., is a professor in the Liberal Studies and Political Studies departments at Vancouver Island University. He has published articles and book reviews on a variety of topics, including Abraham Lincoln’s statesmanship, Jean-Jacques Rousseau’s political philosophy, and Thomas D’Arcy McGee’s contribution to Canadian confederation.
and David Hunt
David Hunt
David Hunt
David Hunt is the research director at the Aristotle Foundation for Public Policy.
November 18, 2026Updated: November 18, 2026

Commentary

Today, too many Canadian children reach the end of Grade 3 without the reading skills they need to succeed. The problem is not new. Nor is it confined to a particular province, although some perform better than others. Yet despite compelling evidence about how children learn to read, many schools retain teaching methods that have failed too many students.

Let’s go back to October 2022. That’s when the Ontario Human Rights Commission (OHRC) published its landmark Right to Read report, exposing serious shortcomings in Ontario’s approach to reading instruction. According to the report, in 2018, only 62 percent of Ontario Grade 3 students met the provincial reading standard without assistance.

In other words, more than one in three failed to meet the basic provincial standard—and that standard is not high.

What about other provinces? In a new report for the Aristotle Foundation for Public Policy, we dive into the numbers.

Short answer: With scant exceptions, other provinces aren’t any better.

We have Grade 3 data for two other provinces, in addition to Ontario. In Manitoba, a staggering 56 percent of Manitobans cannot read by the end of Grade 3. In Nova Scotia, it is 28 percent.

Four provinces report Grade 4 data. Half of New Brunswick students cannot read in Grade 4. In Quebec and B.C., Grade 4 illiteracy is 31 percent and 30 percent, respectively. In Alberta, one in five Grade 4 students are illiterate. (However, the most recent Alberta data is from 2021. Given trends, it is possible that their results are just as bad as the other provinces.)

On their own, these figures should alarm parents, educators, and policymakers. But the problem does not simply disappear as children grow older.

According to the latest results from the Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA), 22 percent of Canadian 15-year-olds fell below the baseline for functional literacy in 2025, while another 23 percent barely reach it. And the proportion performing below basic proficiency is (steeply) trending in the wrong direction.

Importantly, in an increasingly complex digital and information economy, meeting the baseline is now insufficient. This must be emphasized. Moreover, the evidence suggests that early reading difficulties are not easily corrected in later grades and follow students into adulthood.

This is more than an educational concern. Poor literacy is associated with poverty, poorer health, and difficulties adhering to medical treatment. Research has also linked improvements in literacy to higher economic productivity.

The Canadian Association of Chiefs of Police has emphasized the role of improved literacy in crime prevention. Criminal offenders are three times more likely than the average Canadian to have literacy problems. And a functioning democracy depends on citizens who can read, understand competing arguments, and participate meaningfully in public debate. Those who struggle with literacy may struggle to fulfill their civic responsibilities and contributing to the common good.

The greatest injustice is to the children themselves. Failing to teach them to read effectively limits their future. Children who are socioeconomically challenged are likely to be harmed the most by ineffective methods of teaching literacy. This is unfair and unnecessary.

But there’s hope.

University of Alberta researcher George Georgiou developed a program providing targeted reading instruction four times a week. In a 2026 study involving 1,000 students in five provinces, 80 percent improved by the equivalent of a year and a half in five months, and half no longer required intervention.

For example, in Fort Vermilion, Alberta, superintendent Michael McMann introduced Prof. Georgiou’s evidence-based reading program. It is noteworthy that this is a particularly challenging district for literacy, due to the share of students whose primary language at home is not English. And yet, Grade 9 reading proficiency subsequently increased from 43 to 86 percent. The results demonstrate the potential benefits of changing instructional practices.

It is time we implement reforms, to see similar improvement in other school districts.

Literacy is not an optional educational outcome. It is the foundation on which students acquire knowledge, exercise judgment, and participate fully in society. Every year governments and education institutions delay reform, more children are left without that foundation.

The evidence is clear. It is time for Canadian leaders, in government and education, to act.

David W. Livingstone, PhD, is a senior fellow and David Hunt is the research director at the Aristotle Foundation for Public Policy.

Views expressed in this article are the opinions of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of The Epoch Times.

Muslims Set to Outnumber Christians Worldwide Within a Decade: Study
RELATED
Parents, Voters Have Less Say in Education as School Boards Expand in Canada, Study Says