Widespread reliance on outdated teaching practices has pushed literacy in Canada to historic lows, leaving Grade 10 students two to three years behind where their counterparts were 25 years ago in reading proficiency, according to a new study.
The study by the Aristotle Foundation, a Calgary-based public policy think tank, examines how children learn to read and contrasts what it calls “evidence-based” teaching methods with approaches still widely used in Canadian classrooms.
The authors urge provinces to replace “cueing strategies,” which encourage students to guess words using context and pictures, with “structured literacy,” which systematically teaches how sounds correspond to written letters and words. They also recommend curricula that build vocabulary and background knowledge, along with early screening and targeted help for struggling readers.
“We know that 95 percent of children can learn to read, but around a third do not, because of outdated teaching methods,” lead author David Livingstone said in a press release. “Every year that provincial governments and education institutions delay reform, more children are left without the necessary foundation to fully participate in society.”
A Nov. 13 report by the foundation found 38 percent of students in Canada are unable to read at a functional level by the end of Grade 3. It also found that 23 percent of 15-year-olds fall below the baseline for functional literacy, showing that early reading gaps rarely close as children grow older.
Teaching Approaches
Balanced literacy, a teaching approach widely used in Canadian classrooms, encourages students to guess words from context rather than systematically decode them, the study said.
“The idea is to learn literacy like infants learn language,” the authors said. “The assumption is that both are natural acquisitions and learners just catch on.”
The authors argue that encouraging children to guess words from pictures reinforces poor reading habits and impedes word recognition. They also said this method is particularly difficult for students with learning challenges, such as dyslexia, as well as for those learning English as a second language.
All students learn better with what is known as “structured literacy,” or the “science of learning,” the study said.
The study argued the science of learning should shape teaching practices and guide Canadian curricula, and said it remains a “largely unused tool in the school toolbox.”
The authors cited a 2026 literacy study led by George Georgiou of the University of Alberta. The research project demonstrated that short, targeted sessions can rapidly close early reading gaps.
The intervention reached 1,000 struggling Grade 2 readers in Alberta, British Columbia, Ontario, Quebec, and Saskatchewan.
Students received small-group instruction four times a week for 30 minutes per session over five months. Eighty percent of participating students improved their reading skills by the equivalent of 1.5 grade levels over five months, according to the study.
“Georgiou’s use of structured literacy to transform struggling readers into competent ones provides compelling evidence of what works in a Canadian context,” the authors wrote.
Resistance to Reform
The authors referred to a 2022 report by the Ontario Human Rights Commission (OHRC) which found that the province’s public education system is failing students with reading disabilities.
The OHRC report said decades of science-backed studies of literacy have not been introduced into Canadian school systems due to “strong, deeply rooted resistance to change in the education field.”
One example of that resistance cited in the Aristotle report was when the Ontario government tried to introduce early intervention screening.
“The mandate was watered down because the Elementary Teachers’ Federation of Ontario and the Ontario English Catholic Teachers’ Association made a formal complaint to the Ontario Labour Relations Board, claiming that mandating early intervention screening—i.e., following the preponderance of evidence—undermined their ‘professional judgment’ as teachers,” the authors said.
The study also cited opposition in British Columbia after Dyslexia BC urged the province to adopt structured literacy, as recommended by the OHRC.
The BC Teachers’ Federation responded by saying teachers have the expertise to decide how students in their classrooms should engage with reading and writing, the study said.
“But falling literacy rates…suggest that the ‘teacher-knows-best’ approach yields inferior outcomes,” the authors wrote. “Canadian declines have long been in the making and precede COVID learning loss by at least a decade. In other words, there are structural reasons for Canada’s decline in literacy.”
Dyslexia Canada created a website that tracks how well each province is progressing toward adopting structured literacy, the study noted.
The site listed four provinces—Alberta, New Brunswick, Nova Scotia and Ontario—as having removed cueing strategies from their curricula and instructional guidance as of its August 2025 update.
But none of those four has updated teacher licensing requirements to require proficiency in the structured literacy approach. And although Alberta has mandated evidence-based curricula and screening tools, no province requires schools to use evidence-based interventions.
“This lack of sufficient follow-through helps explain why reading proficiency rates have shown little improvement or declined in recent years,” the authors said.
The study recommends provinces implement the OHRC’s 157 recommendations from its “Right to Read” report to address long-standing gaps in literacy instruction.
“For literacy to improve, Canadian provinces need to prioritize evidence-based teaching strategies for reading, use a knowledge-rich curriculum, apply science-of-learning principles, and implement early and rigorous reading interventions,” the authors said.
“Without immediate action, students will continue to enter later grades and adulthood without foundational literacy skills, limiting their opportunities and long-term success.”

