Federal Judge Halts DHS Restrictions on Foreign Students’ Training

By Tom Gantert
Tom Gantert
Tom Gantert
Tom Gantert is a reporter for The Epoch Times.
November 17, 2026Updated: November 17, 2026

A federal judge on Nov. 17 temporarily blocked new federal restrictions on internships and other practical training for international students.

U.S. District Judge Julia Kobick in Massachusetts said the Department of Homeland Security likely violated the Administrative Procedure Act when it changed a policy that had been in place since 1991.

Kobick said DHS changed the policy allowing international students to take elective internships for academic credit without acknowledging or explaining the change. She said the department also failed to consider how schools and students had relied on the previous policy.

The dispute concerns curricular practical training, which allows students on F-1 visas to participate in internships and other training tied to their studies.

The judge temporarily blocked the government from enforcing the new restrictions anywhere in the country while the lawsuit continues. She also specifically barred it from applying those restrictions to the groups that sued, their members, their schools, and those schools’ employees and students.

Immigration and Customs Enforcement said it doesn’t comment on pending litigation.

The judge ruled that the plaintiffs—the Association of American Universities, Presidents’ Alliance on Higher Education and Immigration, Association of Independent Colleges and Universities in Massachusetts, and NAFSA: Association of International Educators—were likely to win.

The schools faced immediate harm from the time and money spent changing programs, the judge said. She added that there were also threats of losing authorization to enroll international students and potential criminal liability for school officials.

She concluded that those harms outweighed the government’s reasons for enforcing the restrictions while the lawsuit proceeds.

DHS said the restrictions were intended to ensure that international students’ practical training met federal requirements. In its August directives, the agency said it had observed an increase in training authorizations that were not integral to an established curriculum. It maintained that qualifying training must be essential to completing a degree and required for all students pursuing that degree.

In its Aug. 12 directive, DHS said it was increasing scrutiny of training approvals after observing the rise in authorizations.

According to the ruling, the August directives had disrupted fall internships and prompted universities to reconsider their academic requirements.

Columbia University said it denied fall training authorization to more than 120 international students and revised its career guidance sessions. At Grinnell College, at least 13 students lost internship opportunities. Cornell University and Michigan State University reported losing students because of the directives.

Some Cornell programs considered making practical training mandatory for all students to preserve international students’ eligibility. Washington University in St. Louis said reviewing and modifying curricula diverted faculty and administrators from their other responsibilities.

School officials also reported concerns about personal legal exposure. Dartmouth College and Vanderbilt University described a chilling effect on officials responsible for approving training because they feared prosecution.

The government countered that the directives merely explained existing regulations rather than changed policy. It also maintained that schools and students could not reasonably rely on informal agency guidance.

Kobick rejected those arguments. She noted the government’s explanation accompanying its 1991 regulation and subsequent guidance allowing elective training for academic credit.

An agency can change its position, the judge said, but must acknowledge the change, provide reasons, and consider significant reliance on the previous policy. She said the government likely failed to meet those obligations.

The ruling does not resolve every legal question raised by the lawsuit. Because Kobick found the plaintiffs likely to succeed on their claim that the directives were arbitrary and capricious, the restrictions remain blocked while the case continues.

Democrat Mary Peltola Flips US Senate Seat in Alaska
RELATED
Judge Blocks Trump Admin Visa Rule on Foreign Students, Media