Peter Menzies: Canadians May Soon Be Able to Again Post News Links on Facebook and Instagram

By Peter Menzies
Peter Menzies
Peter Menzies
Peter Menzies is a senior fellow with the Macdonald-Laurier Institute, an award winning journalist, and former vice-chair of the Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission.
November 19, 2026Updated: November 19, 2026

Commentary

Canadians can expect to see the return of news links on Facebook and Instagram early in the new year, if not sooner.

That will be, oddly, thanks to U.S. President Donald Trump and his trade negotiators who, as part of the give and take involved in such matters, have so far convinced Prime Minister Mark Carney and his team to abandon the core of two pieces of legislation—the Online Streaming Act and the Online News Act.

It is the latter (we can deal with the former on another day) that led to news links being unavailable on Facebook and Instagram. This is how that happened:

The Online News Act was premised on the accusation made by representatives of the news industry that Meta, owner of Facebook and Instagram, was effectively stealing content from publishers, posting it on their platforms, and failing to compensate them for it. No evidence was ever presented to support this allegation. Meta maintained that the choice to post content on its platforms is made freely by its users and that by giving the publishers free access to its platforms, it was providing them with more than $200 million in commercial value.

The government chose to align itself with the publishers’ version of events and created the Online News Act in order to force Meta and Google to pay news organizations hundreds of millions of dollars annually for every link that they chose to post or was picked up. As global companies, both recognized that if Canada was successful in implementing its plan, other countries would likely duplicate what some politicians were boasting was world-leading legislation and the dollar costs would be in the tens, if not hundreds, of billions.

So, shortly after the Online News Act was passed, Meta made good on what the publishers had assumed was a bluff and, beginning in August 2023, blocked anyone in Canada from posting or viewing news links from anywhere in the world and ended its funding of journalism projects.

Google chose a different route. In exchange for being excluded from the act, it essentially paid a ransom through the establishment of a fund distributing $100 million annually to news organizations, including $7 million for the CBC and roughly $30 million for other broadcasters. The publishers got to split the remaining $63 million or so but lost any commercial agreements they might have had with Google. The value of those agreements has never been revealed, but it has been estimated, without contention, to be at least $30 million and as much as $50 million.

The publishers and the government framed this as a victory, although the end result appears to have been that the combined reductions in revenue through the loss of commercial agreements, sponsorships, and exposure via Facebook and Instagram amounted to somewhere between $250 million and $300 million annually, while the revenue earned in return amounts to a $100 million fund. To help make up for this considerable loss, government-approved news organizations successfully lobbied for extension and expansion of tax credits and other subsidies (confirmed in the recent budget) worth several hundred million dollars.

Also this year, against a background of Canada–USA trade talks, Meta and other Big Tech companies lobbied in Washington for relief from Ottawa’s efforts to dip into their pockets (the Biden administration was similarly opposed) and the Online News Act was put on the trade negotiations table. Meta then began talks in Ottawa on how to bring an end to its obligations under the act. In exchange for that relief, when it comes, Meta is believed to be willing to drop its ban on the posting of links and offer some (non-financial) assistance to Canadian news organizations, likely in terms of exposure.

So if as part of a renewed trade agreement between Canada and the United States, the Online News Act will be, if not revoked, revised in some fashion to exclude Meta, then links, perhaps with enhanced prominence, will again be posted on Facebook and Instagram.

Where that leaves Google and its $100 million fund is anyone’s guess. Should the government undertake to revoke the Online News Act, it seems that would mean an end to that obligation and a return to commercial agreements, which these days probably have a lot more to do with artificial intelligence (AI) than links. My guess is that Canada will keep the act in place but with side deals excluding the only two companies to which it ever applied anyway—Meta and Google.

It’s entirely possible, however, that such an arrangement wouldn’t be acceptable to Big Tech as it would leave the door open to similar shakedowns elsewhere in the world.

We shall see, and circumstances can change quickly. Deals can fall apart. But as things stand, it’s looking like Canadians will soon be able to read and post news links again on Facebook and Instagram. If this happens, expect both the government and the industry to declare victory, when in fact both will be rectifying one of the century’s most significant policy errors.

Views expressed in this article are the opinions of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of The Epoch Times.

Key Takeaways From Trump’s Asia Trip
RELATED
Peter Menzies: Future Decisions on Canada’s Immigration Levels Will Be Critically Important