Affirmative Action Is Dead. Discrimination Against Asian Americans Isn’t.

By Charis Ralko
Charis Ralko
Charis Ralko
Charis Ralko is a senior admissions consultant at Ivy Coach and served as an associate director of admissions at Washington University in St. Louis.
November 17, 2026Updated: November 17, 2026

Commentary

In the Supreme Court’s landmark 2023 decision in Students for Fair Admissions (SFFA) v. Harvard, one of SFFA’s central arguments was that race-conscious admissions policies systematically discriminated against Asian American applicants. Data from the National Center for Education Statistics shows that Asian American students, on average, outperform other racial and ethnic groups on the SAT and ACT. While test scores, of course, aren’t the only factor in admissions decision-making, nor should they be, the Supreme Court’s ruling seemed likely to produce a surge in Asian American enrollment at elite universities. But did it?

The Numbers Tell a Different Story

At some institutions, yes. At MIT, Asian American enrollment jumped from 40 percent to 47 percent in the Class of 2028, the first class admitted after the ruling. Stanford’s Asian American enrollment rose that year from 36.5 percent to 41.3 percent. But the trend was far from across the board. At Harvard, Asian American enrollment remained flat at 37 percent in the Class of 2028, while at Yale, it actually fell from 30 percent to 24 percent. Princeton saw a decline as well, from 26 percent to 23.8 percent. The Class of 2029 brought a reversal at several institutions, with Asian American enrollment climbing to 41 percent at Harvard, 30 percent at Yale, and 27.1 percent at Princeton. Yet the Class of 2030 showed that these gains were hardly assured. At Princeton, Asian American enrollment fell back to 23 percent, below its pre-ruling level. Three admissions cycles after the Supreme Court’s landmark ruling, the results remain decidedly mixed.

How Bias Survives a Supreme Court Ruling

So why haven’t we seen a more consistent increase in Asian American enrollment after the SCOTUS ruling? As a former Washington University in St. Louis admissions officer and current Senior Admissions Consultant at Ivy Coach, a Manhattan-based college consulting firm, I believe discrimination against Asian American applicants persists, and several features of the admissions process help explain how.

First, the Supreme Court left universities an opening. In the majority opinion, Chief Justice John Roberts explained that universities could still consider an applicant’s discussion of how race shaped his or her life. Highly selective universities subsequently revised supplemental essay prompts to emphasize cultural identities, backgrounds, and communities. Although the Court prohibited universities from using essays to circumvent its ruling, subjective essay evaluations leave ample room for race to influence admissions decisions.

Then there’s the notorious “personal rating.” During the SFFA v. Harvard litigation, evidence revealed that Asian American applicants routinely received lower personal rating scores than other racial groups, despite strong academic and extracurricular ratings. Personal ratings remain important, and rightly so. Universities should certainly consider character, intellectual curiosity, and interpersonal qualities. But unlike test scores or transcripts, these evaluations are inherently subjective. Admissions officers, like everyone else, harbor implicit biases. Those biases didn’t magically disappear with the Supreme Court’s ruling.

We observe another challenge facing Asian American applicants. Too often, students gravitate toward similar extracurricular pursuits, including piano, math competitions, and fencing. And there is, of course, nothing wrong with these interests. But when academically accomplished applicants present nearly identical profiles, differentiation, which is the name of the game in the highly selective college admissions process, becomes extraordinarily difficult. Elite universities aren’t seeking thousands of interchangeable applicants with stellar grades and impressive test scores. Instead, they’re building classes of students with distinctive talents to form a well-rounded class. For Asian American applicants, familiar extracurricular profiles can also reinforce stereotypes already held by admissions officers. But the solution isn’t abandoning genuine interests. Rather, it’s developing a singular, compelling narrative that makes an applicant impossible to overlook.

And therein lies another interesting wrinkle. Harvard’s enrollment of students from China increased this past fall, even as the Trump administration sought to restrict visas and international enrollment. Although elite universities generally don’t publish formal international enrollment caps, international students often make up roughly 10 percent to 15 percent of their undergraduate student bodies (though Columbia, as part of its settlement with the Trump administration, agreed to reduce its financial dependence on international enrollment). Chinese applicants therefore compete against students worldwide for a relatively limited number of seats, a challenge compounded by the tendency of many, much like their Asian American counterparts, to pursue similar academic and extracurricular interests that make it more difficult to stand out.

But What About Recruited Athletes?

But perhaps the most revealing development isn’t simply how much Asian American enrollment increased at certain institutions. It’s also whose enrollment declined when it did. At MIT, the combined percentage of Black, Hispanic, and Indigenous students fell from 25 percent to 16 percent following the ruling. Meanwhile, the proportion of recruited athletes remained unchanged. Recruited athletes have long enjoyed a substantial leg up in admissions, often entering with significantly weaker academic credentials than non-recruited students. So why did increased Asian American enrollment seemingly come at the expense of historically underrepresented minority students rather than, say, recruited athletes? Do our nation’s most selective universities really need more squash players?

It’s Time for Universities to Show Us the Numbers

Ultimately, enrollment statistics alone can’t establish discrimination. Instead, they reveal who arrived on campus, not who applied, who was admitted, or why. And that’s what brings us to the most important issue, which is transparency. The Common Data Set, a standardized annual report of college admissions and enrollment statistics, provides extensive information about enrolled students but not racial breakdowns of applicant pools and admitted students. The Trump administration has moved to require universities to report more detailed admissions data by race, a welcome step toward accountability. But collecting the numbers isn’t enough. The public deserves to see them.

The Supreme Court may have ended affirmative action on paper, but whether it ended discrimination in practice remains an open question. Until universities are forced to reveal the numbers, their claims of race-neutral admissions aren’t worth the paper they’re printed on.

Views expressed in this article are the opinions of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of The Epoch Times.

Day in Photos: Honoring Fallen Soldiers, Protest in Venezuela, and Voices of Early Americas
RELATED
DOJ: Duke University Law School Discriminated Against White and Asian Applicants