Commentary
A couple of weeks ago, I wrote an article about Calley Means leaving the Trump administration. People were questioning whether his departure represented a fracture in the Make America Healthy Again movement. Had he given up? Was Robert F. Kennedy Jr. compromising too much by staying?
I offered a different possibility.
“But what if neither Kennedy nor Means has given up? What if they’re simply employing different strategies?”
I went on to write that perhaps Kennedy believed he needed to remain inside the institution, even defend parts of it, to accomplish the changes he came to make, while Means believed he could accomplish more from the outside.
The day my article was published, Calley took a screenshot of that passage and sent it to my brother, Ryland Engelhart, telling him I was very perceptive.
I didn’t know what Calley was planning. I was simply considering whether two men working toward the same goals might serve the mission through different approaches.
Then on Friday November 6, while I was knee-deep in mud hosting the Exit and Build festival at our ranch in Texas, Calley Means went on Joe Rogan and started naming names.
For days, I had been dealing with torrential rain, flooded camping areas, guests needing assistance, and a fever of my own. I was so consumed with the immediate needs of people on our land that I had barely paid attention to Washington.
When I finally caught up, Means was demonstrating what working outside the institution could look like.
Means accused senior White House officials of prioritizing corporate interests and political fundraising over the health reforms that helped bring Kennedy’s supporters into Trump’s coalition.
He named Chief of Staff Susie Wiles, political adviser James Blair, and Trump pollster Tony Fabrizio, alleging that people close to the president had interfered with policies concerning pesticides, ultra-processed foods, pharmaceuticals, and nicotine products.
Just hours after the interview was released, Trump announced that Wiles was leaving and Stephen Miller would replace her.
Reports indicate that her departure was already under discussion following Republican midterm losses. We cannot conclude that Means caused her removal. But the timing was remarkable. Means had publicly challenged one of Washington’s most powerful officials, and by the end of the day, she was on her way out.
Means later acknowledged that removing Wiles had been one of his objectives.
One of the most revealing things Means said on Rogan was that people surrounding Trump were treating the president “like a baby.”
I have heard something directly from people who have met with Trump that makes this allegation particularly interesting.
During one meeting, someone brought up cancer rates along the Mississippi River and in Iowa. According to someone who was personally present at the meeting and confirmed the exchange with me, Trump responded, “That’s terrible. How come nobody has told me this?”
Think about that.
The president of the United States was hearing information about serious public health concerns and asking why nobody had brought it to his attention before.
Of course, a president cannot know everything. That is why he has advisers. But who decides what information reaches him? Who decides which problems deserve his attention and which ones never make it onto his desk?
And if the people controlling that flow of information have relationships with corporations whose products and practices are being questioned, how can the public be confident the president is receiving the full picture?
We spend enormous amounts of time fighting over who gets elected while paying far less attention to the unelected people who help determine what those elected officials actually know.
This brings me back to another observation from my original article.
“Perhaps we have confused getting our people into positions of power with actually changing where power resides.”
When Kennedy became secretary of Health and Human Services, many believed that having someone willing to challenge pharmaceutical companies, food corporations, and regulatory agencies inside the government would fundamentally change those institutions.
I shared that hope. But the machinery of government does not disappear when a new person takes charge.
The agencies remain. The lobbyists remain. The campaign contributions remain. And the companies whose profits depend on existing policies have every incentive to protect them.
One of the most troubling parts of Means’s account involves glyphosate, the active ingredient in Roundup, now owned by Bayer following its acquisition of Monsanto.
Means described internal efforts to support policies favorable to Bayer while Kennedy and other MAHA advocates pushed for greater scrutiny of pesticides.
The administration had already taken actions supporting glyphosate production and Bayer’s legal position. Were those decisions independent policy judgments, or were corporate relationships and political calculations influencing them?
As a regenerative farmer, I work every day with the consequences of agricultural decisions made far away from the land. Farmers are told which chemicals are necessary and which systems we must participate in to survive. Meanwhile, the companies manufacturing agricultural inputs have enormous resources to influence the policies governing their products.
Means also alleged that efforts to define ultra-processed foods faced resistance from political advisers concerned about industry opposition.
We have an enormous national conversation about childhood obesity, diabetes, chronic disease, and declining health, yet even defining ultra-processed food has become a political fight.
Kennedy can direct agencies, appoint officials, and pursue reforms. Those powers matter. But he must work within an administration where health policy competes with political priorities, economic interests, and relationships that existed long before he arrived.
Means has surrendered institutional authority, but he has gained something else.
He can describe what he says happened behind closed doors, identify the people he believes interfered with reform, and speak directly to millions of Americans without permission from the administration he once served.
That doesn’t make every allegation true. Several people Means named have denied his accusations. But it makes those allegations available for public examination.
Kennedy, meanwhile, publicly celebrated Miller’s appointment as chief of staff, calling him one of the administration’s strongest MAHA supporters.
Does Kennedy genuinely believe Miller will help him accomplish what Wiles allegedly obstructed? Is he supporting the president’s decision because maintaining that relationship is essential to his work? Or are both things true?
I don’t know his private motivations, but the contrast illustrates the different positions these men occupy.
During our festival this weekend, hundreds of people gathered to discuss exiting systems they no longer trust and building alternatives. Then the weather stripped away many comforts they had come to expect. Suddenly, people discussing independence found themselves depending on one another for transportation, shelter, food, and help getting through the mud.
Some people were physically strong. Others were organizers. Some repaired equipment, while others cared for people who were struggling. We needed all those skills.
I think movements work the same way.
We need people inside institutions who understand the regulations, relationships, and compromises necessary to change policy. We need people outside who can question those institutions, expose their failures, and create public pressure. And we need people building alternatives so our future doesn’t depend exclusively on who holds office.
The mistake is believing everyone must employ the same strategy to fight for the same outcome.
Kennedy has the authority to act inside government. Means has the freedom to challenge it publicly.
When I wrote that neither man had necessarily given up, I wasn’t making a prediction. I was questioning our tendency to interpret every departure as defeat and every compromise as surrender.
But a larger question remains.
Can we change our food and health systems simply by putting different people in charge, or must we change the incentives that determine how those systems operate?
If corporate money continues shaping public policy and the same lobbying relationships determine which reforms advance, we may find ourselves celebrating changes in leadership without changing much at all.
I hope Kennedy succeeds from the inside. I hope Means’s allegations receive serious scrutiny from the outside. And I hope we remember that making America healthy again cannot be the responsibility of two men, one administration, or one political party.
It must also happen in our kitchens, on our farms, in our communities, and in the alternatives we are willing to build.
There is work to be done on both sides of the institution.
Views expressed in this article are the opinions of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of The Epoch Times.

