Land Acknowledgments: Teaching Children to Doubt Their Right to Belong

By Patrick Keeney
Patrick Keeney
Patrick Keeney
Patrick Keeney, Ph.D., is an academic and columnist. He is the author of “Liberal Learning and the Modern University: Reclaiming the Intellectual and Moral Foundations of Higher Education.”
November 15, 2026Updated: November 15, 2026

Commentary

What, precisely, are Canadian children supposed to learn when their school day begins with a declaration that the land they stand on belongs, in some historical, ancestral, or moral sense, to someone else?

This question is worth asking, particularly in light of the legal dispute between Dr. Geoffrey Horsman and the Waterloo Region District School Board. Horsman, a parent of three, challenged the board’s insistence on land acknowledgements at school council meetings and its refusal to permit debate about the practice. The resulting litigation raises important constitutional questions about freedom of conscience and expression.

But a deeper educational question deserves far more attention than it has received. What exactly are we teaching our children about their country, citizenship, identity, and their rightful place in the national community?

Land acknowledgements are often defended as gestures of reconciliation and as reminders of Canada’s obligations to indigenous peoples. These are legitimate lines of inquiry. No history of Canada requires us to romanticize the past or pretend that its treatment of indigenous peoples has always been honourable.

But acknowledging historical wrongs is one thing. Encouraging children to see themselves as inheritors of a nation whose legitimacy is questionable is quite another.

Consider the moral implications of repeatedly and solemnly telling children that the land on which their school stands is the traditional territory of another people. What are they to understand? Are they guests, intruders, or interlopers whose right to belong remains uncertain? Might they come to believe that their home, family, and community rest on an unresolved moral trespass?

The possible emotional consequences for our children deserve careful consideration. Might such declarations be likely to foster guilt or anxiety in children? Or to leave a child wondering whether the country he calls home is truly his to inhabit? And why do we think it pedagogically wise for children to receive a message whose historical and political complexities they cannot yet be expected to grasp?

Defenders of land acknowledgements insist that their purpose is to cultivate historical understanding and respect for Indigenous peoples. Yet good intentions do not absolve educators of responsibility for the messages they convey. The proper measure of an educational practice is not merely what adults intend to teach, but what children are likely to learn. This includes the troubling moral implications they may draw from solemn words repeated under the authority of the school.

Children are neither constitutional lawyers nor historians. Land acknowledgements may leave them with the impression that Canada’s very existence remains suspect, that their place within it is uncertain, and that they don’t belong. The danger is that children will absorb a moral verdict before they have the intellectual maturity to assess it. This is where the controversy becomes particularly troubling from an educational standpoint.

Education should cultivate the habits of mind essential to independent judgment: intellectual honesty, historical understanding, reasoned argument, moral discrimination, and a willingness to entertain competing interpretations of complex events. A genuine education teaches students how to think, not what to think.

Ritualized land acknowledgements invert this relationship. Rather than being presented as historical propositions to be examined, they are pronounced as unconditional truths. In this respect, they bear an uncomfortable resemblance to religious decrees: solemnly recited, invested with moral authority, and placed beyond ordinary questioning. The school assumes something disturbingly close to the authority of a church, prescribing what to believe rather than inviting students to discover what is true.

In this respect, the Horsman case is revealing. The reported refusal by the Waterloo School Board to allow discussion of land acknowledgements at a school council meeting raises a disturbing question: if an educational institution cannot tolerate reasoned debate about its own moral pronouncements, how exactly does it understand its educational mission?

The irony is considerable. Schools that profess to cultivate critical thinking simultaneously insist that certain propositions remain beyond criticism.

Like every nation, Canada’s history is neither an unblemished chronicle of progress nor an uninterrupted catalogue of oppression. It is a complex inheritance, encompassing achievement and failure, generosity and injustice, aspiration and disappointment, triumph and tragedy, heroes and villains. Understanding it requires historical knowledge, proportion, and judgment.

Above all, historical understanding requires distinguishing between responsibility for past wrongs and the moral standing of those living today. Children born in Canada have committed no offence by virtue of their citizenship. Their citizenship should not be a source of historical embarrassment or inherited shame that demands perpetual apology. Nor should their right to belong depend on the circumstances of their ancestors’ arrival, whether yesterday or centuries ago.

Indeed, the implications are especially worrying for children whose families have only recently made Canada their home. Having been welcomed into a new country and encouraged to regard it as their own, what are they to make of a school ritual that seems to suggest otherwise? What message do we send when the very institution charged with fostering their sense of belonging begins by reminding them that the land where they now live properly belongs to someone else?

Surely one of the basic obligations of a public school is to teach children that they belong to the political community into which they were born or welcomed.

This does not diminish indigenous rights, treaty obligations, or the importance of historical truth. Yet a school system that habitually emphasizes Canada’s moral defects, without providing an equally serious account of its achievements, risks producing not informed citizens but estranged ones. That is a poor substitute for educating our youth.

A deeper problem warrants our attention. School boards in Canada were established to give parents and local communities a voice in their children’s education. Yet increasingly, they appear to regard themselves as arbiters of moral and political orthodoxy. By what authority do school boards presume to settle contested historical, moral, and political questions and then place their conclusions beyond debate?

The proper business of education is to open such questions to reasoned inquiry, not to foreclose discussion by administrative decree. Once schools abandon the cultivation of independent judgment in favour of inculcating officially sanctioned beliefs, the line between education and indoctrination readily disappears.

This is precisely the distinction that education exists to preserve.  A school should be a place where students of any age encounter reasoned arguments.  It should not be a place that intentionally closes students’ minds to fraught historical claims announced in advance and then protected from scrutiny.

The Horsman controversy is about much more than constitutional questions. It concerns the intellectual character of our public institutions and the kind of citizens they seek to form. Do we want young Canadians to inherit their country as a common home, worthy of understanding, capable of improvement, deserving of criticism, and, not least, entitled to their affection? Or are we content to teach them to regard that inheritance chiefly as a source of historical guilt and uneasy belonging?

The answer matters. No nation can sustain a flourishing civic life if successive generations are taught to regard their very belonging as something requiring perpetual justification.  Canadian children deserve to know that their citizenship is not a historical trespass and that their right to belong requires neither apology nor justification.

Above all, they deserve schools that cultivate their students’ intellectual abilities so that, in due course, they can judge their national inheritance for themselves. For the last thing Canada, or any free society, needs is an educational establishment that mistakes its authority to teach for a licence to dictate what we all—children and parents alike—must believe.

Views expressed in this article are the opinions of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of The Epoch Times.

Federal Judge Keeps Park Open as Trump Seeks Closure for Renovation
RELATED
Cocktails Don’t Mix Themselves