SHARE
Film Review

‘Rally Caps’: An Adorable ‘Peanuts’ Type Baseball Movie

BY Mark Jackson TIMESeptember 10, 2024

NR | 1h 40m | Comedy, Sports, Family Film | Sept. 10, 2024

There couldn’t have been a more perfect film than “Rally Caps” to premiere at the Field of Dreams Movie Site in Iowa, in August 2024. A delightful baseball movie for kids, “Rally Caps,” is the kind of warm, fuzzy, but also poignant family movie that America needs more of.

boy in baseball catcher's uniform in Rally Caps
Catcher Lucas (Colten Pride) in “Rally Caps.” (Crystal Rock Entertainment)

Based on the novel by Jodi Michelle Cutler and Stephen J. Cutler, “Rally Caps” nails the bitter-sweetness of the 1960s, 1970s, and 1980s American childhood, very similar to Charles M. Schulz’s “Peanuts” comic strip. By that, I mean it manages to capture the nostalgia of an all-encompassing, good-with-the-bad, no-helicopter-parenting, no-soft-landing childhood. Back when a little bit of bullying and classmate-shaming were just par for the course. Just like there’s no light without darkness, when looking back on childhood, it’s the painful things that make the good times stand out.

The Tale

“Rally Caps” tells of one small lad, Jordy (Carson Minniear, extremely adorable), whose dreams of pitching for Little League are so fervent that he routinely lies on his bed practicing fly-ball catching; tossing the ball up to the ceiling and catching it, in excess of 2,000 repetitions per session.

boy in orange shirt and white pants in Rally Caps
Young Jordy (Carson Minniear) lives, eats, and sleeps baseball pitching in “Rally Caps.” (Crystal Rock Entertainment)

His dreams are obliterated when a batter loses control, and the windmilling bat traverses home plate to the pitcher’s mound at a high rate of speed and cracks Jordy in the schnoz. Broken bloody nose-geyser!

This was the straw that broke the camel’s, er, nose. Jordy also happens to be mourning the recent death of his dad; his revered big brother Rob (Ben Morang) moving away, and now this face-altering bat-trauma. Jordy’s done with baseball! He retreats behind the post-surgery protective mask, and never wants to take it off again.

young man in baseball cap in car in Rally Caps
Jordy’s big brother Rob (Ben Morang) is flying the coop, much to his kid brother’s disappointment, in “Rally Caps.” (Crystal Rock Entertainment)

Summer Camp

Jordy heads to summer camp. Even though it’s a sports camp with lots of baseball, and even though he treasures the pitcher’s mitt his late father gifted him, he’s committed to quitting.

boy in orange talks to man in blue in Rally Caps
Jordy (Carson Minniear, R) declares to grandpa (Judd Hirsch) that he’s done with baseball and grandpa is not happy, in “Rally Caps.” (Crystal Rock Entertainment)

He immediately befriends cabin-mate Lucas (Colten Pride), who is deaf and who just had a cochlear implant surgery. Lucas is a catcher, and, per the historically long relationship of pitcher and catcher—the two baseball positions that symbiotically combine into one football quarterback—Jordy learns from Lucas how to deal with his fears. He soon returns to the pitcher’s mound.

boy in red and boy in blue in Rally Caps
Catcher Lucas (Colten Pride, L) and pitcher Jordy (Carson Minniear) bond over bubblegum, in “Rally Caps.” (Crystal Rock Entertainment)

But it’s not exactly a bouncing back! The road back is fraught with terrible things, like being so nervous on the mound that there’s loss of bladder control, accompanied by the howling delight of the (Peanuts) peanut gallery! Remember that stuff? It was just so horrifying for the kid involved. But lows lead to highs.

three men in a baseball field in Rally Caps
(L–R) “Coach Ballgame” (James Lowe), former major leaguer Curtis Pride as himself, and camp assistant baseball coach Rob (Ben Morang) discuss what the team needs to work on, in “Rally Caps.”  (Crystal Rock Entertainment)

Lucas’s deafness helps Jordy’s recovery in that the camp invites baseball legend Curtis Pride to talk to the campers. Curtis Pride is the first (and as of this writing, still the only) deaf player to ever make it into the major leagues. A wonderful touch is that Colten is Curtis Pride’s actual son. And so Jordy gets to see how a setback, disability, or both, can take you out of the game, but only if he lets it.

Performances

older man and daughter watch game on couch in Rally Caps
Herb (Judd Hirsch) and his daughter Nora (Amy Smart) watch Jordy’s live-streamed game, in “Rally Caps.” (Crystal Rock Entertainment)

Judd Hirsch and the perennially underutilized Amy Smart play Herb and Nora, Jordy’s grandfather and mom. Smart does a fine job. Hirsch, who, in the 1970s, played cabbie Alex in the hit sitcom “Taxi,” as well as the psychiatrist everyone wishes they had in Robert Redford’s “Ordinary People” (1980), doesn’t steal the show, but provides great assists to Jordy, like he recently did playing the nutty but extremely wise great-uncle in “The Fablemans.”

little brother and big brother on pitcher's mound in Rally Caps
Jordy (Carson Minniear) and big brother Rob (Ben Morang) have a pep talk, in “Rally Caps.” (Crystal Rock Entertainment)

“Rally Caps” has a warm and sincere throwback feel due preeminently to relative newcomer Carson Minniear’s acting chops. At that age, acting is often less acting than being, and what you see is what you get. Minniear is basically Charlie Brown.

young boy on pitchers mound in Rally Caps
Jordy (Carson Minniear) is finally back where he belongs and bringing the heat, in “Rally Caps.” (Crystal Rock Entertainment)

Charlie Brown—also a pitcher—loved baseball more than life itself, was regularly shamed on the mound by Violet, Patty, and of course Lucy, and often ended up being “the goat.” That was back before “goat” culturally morphed into it’s opposite; the modern “G.O.A.T.” (Greatest Of All Time). Back then, being the goat just meant you were a supreme loser.

Charlie Brown was always hanging his head in shame. But when the school bell rang, he was out the door for some more baseball! Jordy as a Charlie Brown archetype is the heart of “Rally Caps.”

three young girls in the woods in Rally Caps
(L–R) The Rally Cap girls: Lisa (Calee Nowak), Lucas’s sister Nikki (Noelle Pride), and “Mouth” (Camille De La Cruz). The three RC girls are much more supportive of their male teammates than Peanuts’ Lucy, Violet, and Patty are to Charlie Brown, in “Rally Caps.” (Crystal Rock Entertainment)
man in suit and hat with glasses in Rally Caps
“Coach Ballgame” (James Lowe) runs the camp, in “Rally Caps.” (Crystal Rock Entertainment)

Jerry Nathan, aka “Coach Ballgame” (James Lowe) also stands out as the quintessential camp leader; an eternally clowning and goofing camp-paterfamilias of fun, trickster wisdom, nurturing, comfort, and humor.

Overall

This well-made indie film offers effective performances from all three generations portrayed, generously delivering a positive outlook while gently teaching universal life lessons.

boy in baseball uniform in cornfield in Rally Caps
Jordy (Carson Minniear) discovers himself in a Field of Dreams, in “Rally Caps.” (Crystal Rock Entertainment)

What lessons? It empowers children to bounce back from setbacks, gain confidence in themselves, and always strive to keep hope alive. “Rally Caps” has a Jordy-in-a-Field-of-Dreams dream sequence, and this movie debuted in the actual Field of Dreams. We all know from “Field of Dreams” (1989) that sports can re-connect families even in the afterlife, and this family film might just call in your family’s ancestors, to watch over your shoulders and chuckle in your ear, while viewing.

“Rally Caps” will have a worldwide VOD release Sept. 10, 2024.

Promotional poster for "Rally Caps." (Crystal Rock Entertainment)
Promotional poster for “Rally Caps.” (Crystal Rock Entertainment)

‘Rally Caps’
Director: Lee Cipolla
Starring: Judd Hirsch, Amy Smart, Carson Minniear, James Lowe, Colten Pride, Curtis Pride
Not Rated
Running Time: 1 hour, 40 minutes
Release Date: Sept. 10, 2024
Rating: 3 1/2 stars out of 5

Would you like to see other kinds of arts and culture articles? Please email us your story ideas or feedback at features@epochtimes.nyc

Mark Jackson
Film Critic
Mark Jackson is the senior film critic for The Epoch Times and a Rotten Tomatoes-approved critic. Mark earned a bachelor's degree in philosophy from Williams College, followed by classical theater conservatory training, and has 20 years' experience as a New York professional actor. He narrated The Epoch Times audiobook "How the Specter of Communism Is Ruling Our World," available on iTunes, Audible, and YouTube. Mark is featured in the book "How to Be a Film Critic in Five Easy Lessons" by Christopher K. Brooks. In addition to films, he enjoys Harley-Davidsons, rock-climbing, qigong, martial arts, and human rights activism.
You May Also Like