Federal Judge Blocks Key Parts of Trump Admin’s $4 Billion Homelessness Overhaul

By Tom Gantert
Tom Gantert
Tom Gantert
Tom Gantert is a reporter for The Epoch Times.
November 22, 2026Updated: November 22, 2026

A federal judge struck down key parts of the Trump administration’s overhaul of a $4 billion homelessness program.

Judge Mary S. McElroy of the U.S. District Court for the District of Rhode Island ruled on Nov. 20 that the Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) exceeded its authority by setting aside $1.3 billion for new projects that prioritized transitional housing and supportive services over permanent housing.

McElroy’s Nov. 20 ruling also resolved a separate lawsuit brought by a coalition of states led by the state of Washington.

She struck down HUD’s $1.3 billion set-aside but left some grant incentives in place that states had challenged, including extra points for programs that offer sober housing or partner with outpatient treatment providers.

McElroy gave applicants until Dec. 1 to revise and resubmit certain grant applications. She ordered HUD to evaluate each applicant’s latest submission and then award those grants by Dec. 31.

The White House didn’t immediately respond to a request for comment.

HUD said it could legally reserve $1.3 billion for new projects, prioritizing those that provide temporary housing or support services such as counseling and job training.

HUD said it would still use the criteria Congress required to evaluate those projects. After awarding that money, it would use the same criteria to decide which other projects would receive any remaining funds in that round.

HUD planned to fund its top-ranked renewal projects first and verify that it had met separate funding targets for domestic violence projects and permanent housing for families with children.

It would then award the $1.3 billion set-aside from the remaining grant pool, known as Tier 2. McElroy said the set-aside kept projects with a proven record of addressing homelessness, as well as projects that provide permanent housing to homeless families with children and youth, from competing for most of the Tier 2 money.

The judge said that under HUD’s plan, those programs could compete only for whatever money remained in that round of funding after HUD awarded the $1.3 billion in reserved funds.

The National Alliance to End Homelessness and its fellow plaintiffs welcomed the ruling, saying it would protect permanent housing programs and allow communities to decide which services work best for people experiencing homelessness.

In a statement, the coalition said HUD’s plan would have pushed communities away from approaches they had found effective.

The department sought to set aside $1.3 billion for new projects, prioritizing transitional housing and programs that provide support services without housing.

The coalition argued that the shift threatened existing permanent housing programs and would make it harder for local providers to respond to the needs of the people they serve.

The coalition also supported the court’s decision to strike down other grant criteria, including provisions that disadvantaged providers that kept participation in services voluntary.

The plaintiffs said local governments and service providers should be able to compete for federal grants while respecting the needs of domestic violence survivors and using practices they consider effective in keeping people safe.

The coalition said the broader concern was whether people could find and maintain stable housing. It welcomed the order and said it protected their ability to compete for funding.

The Continuum of Care program grew out of federal homelessness assistance enacted in 1987.

In 2009, Congress combined three existing programs to create the current grant program.

Beginning in 2013, HUD shifted toward a “housing first” approach that prioritizes moving people quickly into permanent housing without first requiring sobriety or treatment completion.

HUD said its $4.04 billion homelessness grant plan would emphasize addiction treatment, mental health care, and helping people live independently.

“The ‘housing first’ experiment failed Americans by warehousing the vulnerable without results,” HUD Secretary Scott Turner said in June in a statement.

“This ideology promised to end homelessness. Instead, billions of taxpayer dollars were spent while homelessness increased to record levels. Housing alone will not solve a crisis driven by addiction and mental illness.”

Trump Reacts to Reports That FBI’s Records System Was Hacked
RELATED
Trump Administration to Permanently Cut Off Los Angeles Homelessness Agency