Federal Government Urges 9 States to End ‘Orphan Tax’

By Sylvia Xu
Sylvia Xu
Sylvia Xu
Sylvia Xu is a data journalist on the health care policy team.
November 17, 2026Updated: November 17, 2026

The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) issued a statement on Nov. 16 calling on nine states to stop intercepting survivor benefits from orphans. Those states include Connecticut, Florida, Illinois, Maryland, Minnesota, New York, Pennsylvania, Texas, and Wisconsin.

When children lose a parent, they might get survivor benefits from Social Security based on their parent’s earnings through years of work, according to the federal Administration for Children & Families (ACF). But if the children end up in foster care, states can take the money to reimburse themselves for the costs of fostering them.

The Texas Department of Family and Protective Services recouped $8.6 million of Social Security benefits from about 1,600 children to offset the cost of care paid to providers in 2024. That’s about $5,400 per child a year.

Pennsylvania had taken at least $15.7 million of Social Security money from at least 1,300 children from the beginning of 2020 through June 2023, according to a 2025 report from Resolve Philly and Spotlight PA.

These survivor benefits were intended to support children following the death of a parent, and some states have used them to offset costs, the federal department said in the letters to governors.

The new letters come just one year after President Donald Trump signed an executive order launching the “Fostering the Future” initiative, led by First Lady Melania Trump.

“Every child deserves the financial security their parents worked hard to provide,” said HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. “These benefits are often the last lifeline a parent can leave behind for their child. The Trump Administration will fight to ensure no state can seize these funds through this unconscionable practice.”

State or county child welfare agencies can act as representative payees for children in foster care. They can apply the money to the children’s current needs, according to a 2021 congressional report. That potentially includes the cost of providing foster care, according to attorney Roger Diefendorf, a former California administrative law judge.

“I can accept that such reimbursement can be lawful, but would question whether it is sensible,” Diefendorf told The Epoch Times in written comments.

Diefendorf said the survivor benefits “should be preserved for the child’s individual needs, both while they are in care and when they leave the care system.”

“However, I would not say that reimbursement is unlawful in every case,” he added.

Since the Trump administration first called on 39 states to correct their actions last December, 30 states ended or reformed the practice, according to the federal department. The HHS stated that governors can end what the department called “orphan tax” through signing an executive order without the need for legislative action. Multiple states, including Nebraska, Louisiana, Indiana, and Oklahoma, have done so.

Diverting orphans’ survivor benefits constitutes just 0.22 percent of a state’s child welfare budget, according to the federal estimate. Potential offsets may be available through Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) funding and adoption savings.

A spokesperson from the Illinois Department of Children and Family Services (DCFS) told The Epoch Times that the state conserved all survivor benefits for youth in care since Nov. 1, 2023, by changing the mainframe coding in its youth trust accounting system to “turn off” the function that allowed DCFS to access survivor funds for reimbursement.

Illinois DCFS said it submitted fiscal records documenting that change in June 2026 and reached out to the federal ACF at HHS to correct the “misunderstanding following HHS’s press release this morning.”

The ACF spokesperson told The Epoch Times that “ACF commends any step a state takes to preserve the Social Security survivor benefits that belong to children in foster care. To date, however, Illinois has not provided ACF with legally binding documentation, like an executive order, state law, or a documented, enforceable agency policy, that demonstrates they have ended this practice statewide.”

Ending the diversion of survivor benefits matters more in Illinois than almost anywhere, the ACF said. Children’s length of stay in foster care is longer in Illinois compared with any other state in the nation and 70 percent higher than the national mean, according to federal data.

“The longer a child remains in care, the more time a state has to divert benefits, which means these children stand to lose more of what their parents earned for them than children almost anywhere else,” said the federal agency.

A Wisconsin Department of Children and Families spokesperson told The Epoch Times that Gov. Tony Evers’s 2025–2027 budget request included $3 million to hire a contractor to apply for benefits and manage accounts for children.

The spokesperson said under that budget proposal, “leftover funds would be transferred to the child or their guardian when they leave foster care,” but “it was removed by Republicans in the Joint Committee on Finance and did not make it into the final budget bill.”

Democrats Nominate Hakeem Jeffries as Next House Speaker
RELATED
White House Expands Trump Accounts to Children in Foster Care