Commentary
A couple of weeks ago I wrote in this space about a manufacturing entrepreneur I’d met with who had opened a factory in the United States instead of in the Greater Toronto Area.
The owners are proud Canadians, but the numbers just didn’t make sense for them to set up shop here. So that’s about 50 jobs that have gone stateside.
This story came to mind while reading the flurry of news coverage and commentary concerning automaker Stellantis’s decision to sell one of its plants that has been idle since 2023.
This means over 2,000 jobs that were on lay-off notice will now likely be permanently shuttered. The federal government is accusing Stellantis of violating the terms of an agreement they made, and there’s a lot of finger pointing and questions about who knew what and when.
Let’s put all of this into perspective, though. A couple of thousand jobs matter, but so do 50 jobs—and many instances of 50 jobs can quickly grow to be more than a couple of thousand.
Regular instances of small- or medium-sized businesses relocating to the United States or opening a new shop there receive little to no public attention.
Canada has lost far more than 2,000 jobs, because various federal and provincial policies make this country a less attractive place to do business than the United States.
According to reports from Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada, small- and medium-sized manufacturers alone provide 950,000 jobs across Canada.
That’s a massive number. Small businesses are defined as those with fewer than 100 employees and medium ones are those between 100 and 500 employees.
These companies don’t have the same clout and visibility as a big-time American automaker does, but taken together they have a far greater impact on our economy.
In fact, Canada has about 100,000 automotive jobs in total and only a third of them are with major automotive companies that Canadians could name. The rest are with smaller suppliers.
This is not to pit companies against each other. After all, the suppliers supply the big companies, so it is an ecosystem where the businesses work together.
We should of course attract and retain major automotive jobs in Canada, but it’s time we re-evaluated our approach.
For starters, by focusing so disproportionately on the Stellantis project we give the public a false sense of our economy. You’d think based on all the rhetoric around this one plant that it made up a substantial part of our manufacturing sector. The numbers quoted above, though, show this just isn’t the case. So we’re also giving people a false sense of security that if only the Stellantis jobs were secure, the labour market itself would be fine.
We are also clearly neglecting our other businesses—the small- and medium-sized employers and the other large ones who quietly soldier on. An undue focus on one employer and one category of jobs distorts our approach to economic development.
It can also foster resentment. The small and medium manufacturers I speak with are frustrated that policymakers and economists don’t seem as interested in the health of their businesses as in those of big corporations.
Then there’s the issue of capital allocation when it comes to corporate welfare and bailouts. Over the past 20 years, the federal and Ontario governments have together spent about $60 billion in propping up the auto sector. Some of this is cash up front and some is paid out as a bonus after hitting certain targets. A lot of it is also for EV-specific production lines.
Regardless, that’s a lot of money. It’s well over a million dollars per auto sector job. The industry is very heavily subsidized. And yet, as the Stellantis developments reveal, the subsidization doesn’t even guarantee the jobs stay here.
The smaller manufacturers may get the occasional tax credit for certain hiring practices or R&D initiatives, but otherwise they’re left on their own. In some ways that’s fine, we shouldn’t be in the business of subsidizing private sector jobs. It’s the disconnect that’s the problem.
What would happen if we took some of the effort put into subsidizing auto jobs and repositioned it to foster a better pro-business environment all around?
Instead of forking out $60 billion to a few companies in one sector, we could reallocate that funding towards measures that benefit the economy as a whole.
One reason American states can be more appealing places to set up shop is because they out-compete Canadian jurisdictions on a number of fronts.
Reducing taxes is one easy measure. Decreasing energy rates is more complicated, but it can be done. Energy rates are a key expense at manufacturing facilities. They’re also a reason cited by manufacturers for relocating south.
Then there is red tape reduction. A friend of mine who opened a factory in Virginia said they completed the process in a matter of weeks, whereas past experiences in Canada took over a year—all because of onerous rules and regulations.
If we undertake these measures, the results will surely be more than 2,000 jobs saved and many more created.
The jobs would also be sustainable here over the long-term because of the market conditions. They wouldn’t need regular handouts to make them stay.
Views expressed in this article are the opinions of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of The Epoch Times.

