US Funds for Family Planning Overseas Debate Heats Up

By Gary Feuerberg
Gary Feuerberg
Gary Feuerberg
May 8, 2011Updated: October 1, 2015

LIFE RISKS: A displaced Afghan woman holds her child in Kabul in December 2009. In Afghanistan, one in seven women dies in childbirth and the under-5 mortality rate is the highest in the world. USAID says family planning programs can improve these numbers (Shah Marai/Getty Images )
LIFE RISKS: A displaced Afghan woman holds her child in Kabul in December 2009. In Afghanistan, one in seven women dies in childbirth and the under-5 mortality rate is the highest in the world. USAID says family planning programs can improve these numbers (Shah Marai/Getty Images )
WASHINGTON—For over 45 years, the United States has been an ardent promoter of family planning in developing countries, which proponents say has resulted in greatly reduced maternal and child deaths. But the policy has also engendered its share of controversy from groups concerned that it promotes abortion at the same time.

In the recent budget battles in D.C. over funding of Planned Parenthood in the United States, similar lines were drawn. Now, supporters of overseas family planning programs are worried that USAID funding is also at risk.

The Council of Foreign Relations—an influential, independent, nonpartisan think tank—published a report in late April summarizing research by organizations like the World Health Organization, Population Reference Bureau, and Population Action International, and concludes that not only have USAID family planning programs reduced mother and child mortality rates, but they have also reduced the number of abortions.

The CFR hopes its report, “Family Planning and U.S. Foreign Policy: Ensuring U.S. Leadership for Healthy Families and Communities, and Prosperous, Stable Societies,” will be used to encourage the U.S. government to maintain funding for these programs.

“There is serious talk about drastically cutting international family planning, even though it is one of the most cost-effective foreign assistance programs the United States funds,” says the report.

Isobel Coleman, who co-wrote the report with and Gayle Tzemach Lemmon, spoke at a roundtable at the CFR on April 27 where she described the need for these programs.

Several years ago, she was in a rural village in Afghanistan observing a training session on economic opportunity for women. Afghanistan has one of the highest fertility, lowest contraceptive rates; maternal death during childbirth is high and the under-5 mortality rate is the highest in the world.

Suddenly, in the back of the room there was a commotion and her interpreter told her that a participant was saying, “What good is it to have job training [for women], if I don’t have birth control?”

Even in conservative, Muslim Afghanistan, “the women are aware of contraception and want it,” said Coleman. In Afghanistan, one out of seven women dies in childbirth, making delivery one of the greatest threats a woman faces.

In Sub-Saharan Africa that rate falls to 1 in 31; in the developed countries it is 1 in 4,300, according to Koki Agarwal, a roundtable panelist from Jhpiego, an affiliate of Johns Hopkins University, who also contributed to the report.

Voluntary Family Planning Successes

The use of voluntary family planning internationally, which the United States plays a leading role in, has exploded in the last 50 years. In the developing world, its use increased from less 10 percent in 1965, to 53 percent in 2005, says the report. This represents an increase from 30 million users in 1960, to 430 million in 2008. The result has been a worldwide decline in the average number of children a woman gives birth to from over six to just over three.

The report says that out of 818 million women in the developing world who want to avoid pregnancy, 74 percent now have the means (in 2008). There remains, however, an “unmet need” of 215 million women who want to space their pregnancies or avoid pregnancy altogether, but lack access to effective contraception.

To be clear, the family planning they refer to is voluntary—women making decisions for their families—not to confused with state family planning coercion, such as methods used in China and India.

The regions that have the highest unmet need are Sub-Saharan Africa at 24 percent, and South Asia at 15 percent for married women, aged 15–49 in 2005.

Yemen, with a fertility rate of six children per woman, has the highest unmet need for family planning in the world at 51 percent. The population has doubled in fewer than 20 years, and it has a very young age structure that taxes the country’s resources to provide education and employment.

By spacing births more than 24 months apart, rates of maternal and infant mortality and child mortality dramatically fall. Egypt provides a good success story, according to Agarwal.

Egypt’s health statistics had been similar to many other developing countries, when USAID programs targeted the desire to space births in the early 1990s. As a result, the under-5 mortality rate dropped to one-quarter the 1988 level, and the maternal mortality ratio today is 82, down from 174 per 100,000 live births in 1992–1993.

Read More… Family Planning and Abortion

Spain’s Canary Islands Reel From Surge of Migrants From Africa
RELATED
Italy Fines Meta $887 Million Over Android Users' Data Access