Amish Man Charged with DUI after Horse and Buggy Crashes Into Car: Police

June 13, 2019 Updated: June 13, 2019

An Amish man in Kentucky faces DUI charges after his horse-drawn buggy collided with a car.

Reuben Yoder, 34, was arrested on June 12 by the Smiths Grove Police Department after deputies responded to the scene of a crash in Smiths Grove—a rural part of the state.

Yoder initially claimed that one of his children was driving the buggy when it allegedly sideswiped a car at the intersection of Hydro Pondsville Road and T. Elkins Road, the Bowling Green Daily News reported.

None of Yoder’s seven children, who were all inside the buggy at the time of the accident, admitted to causing the crash. Instead, they told police their father did it.

The children were aged between 9 months and 12-years-old, and his wife, Salome Yoder, was also in the buggy at the time of the accident, according to the report.

No one was injured in the incident.

Police suspected that Yoder, who had slurred speech and bloodshot eyes, was under the influence of alcohol. He was initially given field sobriety tests and later taken to a medical center for evaluation.

Yoder faces 10 felony counts, punishable by up to 5 years in jail.

horse draws an Amish carriage
File photo of a horse drawing an Amish carriage. (Chris Hondros/Getty Images)

‘Had Too Many’: 21-Year-Old Man Allegedly Kills 3 Amish Children

In related news, the man who allegedly struck an Amish horse-drawn carriage in Michigan, killing three children, told officials that he “had too many.”

The crash took place at around 6 p.m. on June 7 in Algansee Township of Branch County, WOOD-TV reported.

The driver, 21-year-old Tyler Jackson Frye, was charged with three counts of operating under the influence, causing death, one count of felony firearm possession, and two counts of operating under the influence causing serious injury, according to the report.

According to The Detroit Free Press, a 2-year-old and a 6-year-old died at the scene of the crash. A 4-year-old was later pronounced dead at the hospital.

Another young child and a woman in the carriage remained hospitalized, State Trooper Seth Reed told the Free Press.

Police said that seven people in all were ejected during the crash. The identities of those who died in the crash were not disclosed.

Documents from the Branch County District Court stated that Frye told police that he drank six beers that day before the crash. He said he couldn’t stop as he was passing over a hill before hitting the carriage, WOOD-TV reported.

The documents also said that Frye admitted to rear-ending the carriage, and when he was asked to take a sobriety test, he refused.

“What’s the point? I have had too many,” he reportedly told police.

Man With 5 Drunken Driving Convictions Crashes Into Amish Buggy, Injuring 7

Another man with five prior drunken driving convictions reportedly hit a horse-drawn buggy carrying seven people in Ohio last year, injuring all passengers and the horse.

Two adults and five children were taken to the hospital, according to Fox8. The father and two of the children were airlifted to Akron Children’s Hospital with serious injuries.

“We were informed this morning that everyone is expected to be okay,” said Sgt. Daniel Kumor of the Ohio State Highway Patrol, according to the report.

Troopers said the children ranged in age from a toddler, up to 7 years old, according to News5 Cleveland.

Police arrested 47-year-old Patrick A. Muscaro on suspicion of operating a vehicle impaired (OVI), the Ohio State Highway Patrol said.

suspect arrested in connection with Amish buggy accident
Patrick A. Muscaro, 47, of West Salem, was arrested on suspicion of OVI and remains in the Ashland County jail. (Ohio State Highway Patrol)

The accident happened on Oct. 14, 2018, just after 7:30 p.m. on U.S. Route 224 in Sullivan Township in Ashland County.

The family had just left their friend’s house and were on their way back home, according to Fox8.

“They just left our house, they came for dinner,” said Jacob, a family friend who asked that his last name not to be used. “I heard the crash and ran out to help and to calm them.”

“I was shocked,” Jacob told Fox8 reporters. “I really didn’t know what to think. I just knew something bad had happened.”

All seven passengers were injured, three seriously.

“I just tried to calm them down,” Jacob said. “The kids were screaming.”

The horse was so badly injured that it had to be put down.

members of the Amish community in a horse and buggy
File photo showing members of the Amish community in a horse and buggy in Nickel Mines, Pa., on Jan. 30, 2007. (William Thomas Cain/Getty Images)

Troopers said the buggy was equipped with reflective tape and three lanterns at the time of the crash.

Muscaro was reportedly not hurt.

Jack Phillips contributed to this report.

Follow Tom on Twitter: @OZImekTOM
Recommended